London Evening Advertiser
- BRITISH MINERS REJECT GOVERNMENT TERMS
- TOURIST LICENSES DISGUISE OWNERS' BUSINESS ACTIVITY
- NATIONALITY OF BRIDES STUMPS CONFERENCE
The page carried an Associated Press despatch from London in which A. J. Cook announced that Britain's miners had voted by a large majority against the Government's settlement terms. Only Yorkshire narrowly favoured acceptance, the miners' executive was described as gloomy and perplexed, and the delegate conference that had recommended the terms was to meet the next day. Closer to home, the paper reported that federal customs officers in London had seized cars whose owners passed as tourists while doing business, and that the department warned of drastic action, with confiscation and a $400 fine as the maximum penalty. A second AP item described a committee struggling with the nationality of married women, using Canadian brides of Americans and Frenchmen to show how a wife could end up with no nationality or with two.
This reading covers three excerpts from a partially read page. The first word or words of the tourist-plate story are illegible and are marked [?]. The Huddart trial, Pig Woman, Tombs prison and McIntosh stories are cut at tile edges and are not included, and the lower-left weather table and the right edge of the bottom tile are damaged. The commentary does not cover how Canadian customs enforced the rules on tourist vehicles, and it does not establish what the 1926 conference concluded on married women's nationality, because the consulted material does not document either point.
Translation
BRITISH MINERS REJECT GOVERNMENT TERMS
London, Nov. 18. — A. J. Cook, the miners' secretary, announced today that the vote of the men was against acceptance of the Government's strike settlement proposals by a large majority. All the large districts were against acceptance by considerable margins, he said, except in Yorkshire, where there was a very small majority in favor of acceptance. The members of the miners' executive, meeting this afternoon to consider the situation, were gloomy and perplexed. The delegate conference which last week recommended that the miners accept the terms will meet tomorrow in an endeavor to solve the difficulty.
TOURIST LICENSES DISGUISE OWNERS' BUSINESS ACTIVITY
[?] license plates have recently been seized in London by officers of the federal customs department, because their owners were not bona fide tourists. Confiscation of the cars and a fine of $400 is the maximum penalty for the importation into Canada of vehicles intended for commercial purposes without the payment of duty. In none of the three cases which have occurred recently has the maximum penalty been imposed, but a warning has been issued by the department that owing to the growing frequency of the practice drastic action will be taken to curb it.
NATIONALITY OF BRIDES STUMPS CONFERENCE
The committee's difficulty lay in the fact that from having no nationality a married woman might be placed in the still more dubious position of having two nationalities. A Canadian girl who marries an American, for instance, now loses her British nationality, but cannot acquire American nationality until after a year's residence in the United States. A proposal has been made to allow her to retain her British nationality for the time being, and this, if adopted by the committee would meet her case, but it would increase the difficulties of a Canadian girl marrying a Frenchman, as she would be British in Canada but French in France, with the children following the father's nationality.
Context
What the November 1926 ballot meant for the coal lockout
The despatch catches the moment when the miners' rank and file overrode their own delegate conference, which had recommended accepting the Government's terms. The Spectator's account a week later shows what followed. The Delegate Conference of the Miners' Federation met on Friday, November 19, the 'tomorrow' of the despatch, to consider the voting. The Spectator recorded 460,806 votes for rejecting the Government's offer and a majority against of 147,606; the acceptance figure in its digitized text does not agree with that majority, so the majority is the reliable number. The conference did not vote to continue a national fight. It adopted a South Wales resolution advising the districts to open negotiations with the coal owners immediately, with the Federation's Executive setting general principles and final settlements subject to the conference. The Spectator concluded that the district votes had prevented any national framework from being saved in the coal settlement. The ballot that rejected national terms therefore led directly to district-by-district bargaining. Cook, who announced the result, had led the miners' resistance for months after the general strike, and that resistance ultimately ended in defeat.
Why the miners were locked out and who A. J. Cook was
The terms the miners rejected came at the end of a dispute that had begun before the May general strike. The royal commission chaired by Sir Herbert Samuel published its report on 10 March 1926 and recommended, among other things, a 13.5% reduction in miners' wages and the withdrawal of the government subsidy that had been propping them up. A general strike followed from 4 to 12 May 1926, called by the Trades Union Congress in an unsuccessful attempt to force the government to prevent wage reductions and worsening conditions for 1.2 million locked-out coal miners. When the TUC gave up, the miners stayed out alone. A. J. Cook, the 'miners' secretary' of the despatch, had been General Secretary of the Miners' Federation of Great Britain since 1924 and was closely identified with the slogan 'Not a penny off the pay, not a minute on the day'. That background explains why the executive described here was 'gloomy and perplexed': after more than six months the men had refused terms their leaders had recommended, yet the federation had no national strategy left to fall back on.
Why a Canadian bride lost her British nationality in 1926
The despatch assumes that a Canadian woman is a British subject, and that was the legal position: Canadian status was a subset of British subject status under the imperial British Nationality and Status of Aliens Act 1914, which Canada adopted through its own Naturalization Act, 1914. The rule that a British woman lost her nationality by marrying a foreigner dated from the Naturalization Act 1870, which provided for the first time that British women who married foreign men should lose their British nationality. Under the 1914 regime, before 1933, a woman lost British subject status even if she did not acquire her husband's nationality. That is exactly the gap the committee was trying to close: a Canadian bride of an American could become stateless while waiting to qualify for American nationality. The one-year residence requirement for the American side is the despatch's own statement. The proposed remedy, letting the wife keep British nationality for the time being, created the opposite problem the article describes for wives of Frenchmen, who would be British in Canada and French in France.
How the law on married women's nationality changed after 1926
British and Canadian law on this point changed only in stages after 1926. The automatic loss of British subject status for a woman who did not acquire her husband's nationality applied only until 1933, which ended the statelessness case the despatch uses as its first example. Full independence came later. The British Nationality Act 1948 marked the first time that married British women gained independent nationality, regardless of the citizenship of their spouses. Canada moved first with its own statute: the Canadian Citizenship Act came into force on 1 January 1947, and it provided for a grant of citizenship to women who had lost British subject status before 1947 upon marriage to a foreign man or his later naturalization. The problem the committee was wrestling with in November 1926 was therefore resolved only in stages over the following two decades.
Original
BRITISH MINERS REJECT GOVERNMENT TERMS
London, Nov. 18. - A. J. Cook, the miners ' secretary, announced today that the vote of the men was against acceptance of the Government's strike settlement proposals by a large majority. All the large districts were against acceptance by considerable margins, he said, except in Yorkshire, where there was a very small majority in favor of acceptance. The members of the miners ' executive, meeting this afternoon to consider the situation, were gloomy and perplexed. The delegate conference which last week recommended that the miners accept the terms will meet tomorrow in an endeavor to solve the difficulty.
TOURIST LICENSES DISGUISE OWNERS' BUSINESS ACTIVITY
[?] license plates have recently been seized in London by officers of the federal customs department, because their owners were not bona fide tourists. Confiscation of the cars and a fine of $ 400 is the maximum penalty for the importation into Canada of vehicles intended for commercial purposes without the payment of duty. In none of the three cases which have occurred recently has the maximum penalty been imposed, but a warning has been issued by the department that owing to the growing frequency of the practice drastic action will be taken to curb it.
NATIONALITY OF BRIDES STUMPS CONFERENCE
The committee's difficulty lay in the fact that from having no nationality a married woman might be placed in the still more dubious position of having two nationalities. A Canadian girl who marries an American, for instance, now loses her British nationality, but cannot acqpire American nationality until after a year's residence in the United States. A proposal has been made to allow her to retain her British nationality for the time being, and this, if adopted by the committee would meet her case, but it would increase the difficulties of a Canadian girl marrying a Frenchman, as she would be British in Canada but French in France, with the children following the father's nationality.
Source: Holding institution