Vossische Zeitung
- Java in Uproar
- The Dictatorship Law
- Poincaré Wins Without Resistance
On 17 November 1926 the Berlin Vossische Zeitung reported on its front page that the revolt in West Java had still not been put down. Insurgents had attacked Laboean and been driven off, but they had cut telephone lines and bridges and left the town isolated, and infantry was being rushed in by motor vehicle. In a signed column, Ministerialdirektor Dr. E. Falck took up the planned 'dictatorship law'. He argued that its central question was what position the Reichswehr's commanders should hold, relative to civilian Reich and state authorities and the police, during a state of emergency. From Paris, the paper described how Poincaré took only minutes to dispose of a Radical deputy's interpellation over a speech by his pensions minister, Louis Marin.
Translation
Java in Uproar
The uprising in West Java has not yet been suppressed. Yesterday evening 500 insurgents launched a strong attack on Laboean. The attack failed after a fierce exchange of fire, but Laboean remains completely isolated. The rebels have destroyed the telephone lines and bridges and blocked the roads. Last night infantry was sent by motor vehicle to the district of Laboean. Work is currently under way to restore the interrupted radio link with Batavia.
The Dictatorship Law
The most important point of this law concerns the question of what position the Reichswehr and its commanders are to hold in the state of emergency, the period in which extraordinary measures are imposed and the basic rights of Germans laid down in the Reich Constitution are temporarily suspended. And this position of the Reichswehr needs to be demarcated from that of the civilian Reich authorities, and even more from that of the civilian authorities of the individual states, in particular their administrative authorities and police offices.
Poincaré Wins Without Resistance
Poincaré settled the Louis Marin incident within a few minutes today at the close of the Chamber's sitting. When the Chamber had finished its budget debate, Poincaré mounted the rostrum and declared that he must demand the postponement of the interpellation by the Radical Hulin concerning the speech of the Minister of Pensions, Marin.
Context
The communist revolt of November 1926 in western Java
The revolt the Vossische Zeitung described had begun only days before this issue. A communist uprising started in West Java on 12 November 1926, and the Council of the Dutch East Indies held an emergency meeting in response. The historian Kankan Xie summarises its course as a major revolt that broke out first in Batavia and was followed by similar uprisings in Bantam (Banten) and West Sumatra. Accounts of the later Boven-Digoel camp also identify Banten as the revolt's centre. The paper's details come from its own wire report: 500 insurgents beaten back at Laboean, telephone lines and bridges destroyed, the radio link to Batavia cut, and infantry sent in by motor vehicle. These sources do not independently confirm those details. Xie notes that existing narratives describe the revolts as ill-prepared, poorly organised and easily suppressed. Against that picture, this report records what was being said five days into the revolt: that a district was still cut off and that the uprising had not yet been put down.
How the Dutch colonial government struck back
The infantry the paper reported being sent toward Laboean were part of a response that soon widened from military operations into a political purge. At the emergency council meeting, Governor General Andries Cornelis Dirk de Graeff insisted that a large number of communist leaders across the Indies be rounded up as soon as possible. In Java the repression of the uprising was led by Captain Theo Becking of the Royal Netherlands East Indies Army. Roughly 4,500 people were accused of taking a direct part in the uprising and were imprisoned or sentenced to death. Xie notes that, as is commonly understood, the Dutch authorities dealt a crushing blow to the Indonesian Communist Party (PKI) and its associated organisations through large-scale arrests, imprisonments, executions and banishments. As a result, the PKI was forced underground and did not play a significant role in Indonesian politics again until many years later.
Why many detainees were exiled to Boven-Digoel rather than tried
The judicial side of the crackdown largely bypassed the courts. De Graeff believed that formal trials would give the detained communists a platform to spread their message, so he decided that they should be exiled instead. The colonial government opened the Boven-Digoel camp to intern communists after the failed 1926 uprisings in Java and Sumatra. At its largest, in 1930, the camp held around 1,300 internees and 700 family members. Internees from Banten, the revolt's centre, lived in their own section of the camp. Some of those caught up in the fighting the paper reported in western Java thus ended up in this exile camp, held without trial.
Louis Marin, a leading conservative in Poincaré's cabinet
The 'Marin incident' centred on Louis Marin, a founding member of the Republican Federation, the largest conservative party of the Third Republic. He served as Minister of Pensions in Poincaré's cabinet from 23 July 1926 to 11 November 1928. Marin carried weight beyond his own department. On 7 October 1926, the US chargé in Paris reported that parliamentary opposition to ratifying the Mellon-Bérenger debt agreement with the United States was real and forceful, and that Marin in particular represented it inside the cabinet. The excerpt does not say what Marin's speech contained, so this evidence cannot connect it to the debt dispute. What the report does show is how Poincaré handled the matter. Instead of letting the Radical deputy Hulin's interpellation open a debate on a minister's remarks, he waited until the budget debate was over and asked for it to be postponed. In the paper's words, this settled the incident within minutes and without resistance.
Original
Java in Aufruhr
Der Aufstand in Westjava ist noch nicht unterdrückt. Gestern abend machten 500 Aufständige einen starken Angriff auf Laboean Der Angriff ist nach einem heftigen Feuergefecht gescheitert, aber Laboean bleibt vollkommen isoliert. Die Telephonverbindungen und Brücken sind von den Rebellen zerstört und die Wege versperrt worden. Heute nacht wurde Infanterie mit Kraftwagen nach dem Distrikt von Laboean abgesandt. An der unterbrochenen Radioverbindung mit Batavia wird zurzeit gearbeitet.
Das Diktaturgesetz
Der wichtigste Punkt dieses Gesetzes betrifft die Frage, welche Stellung die Reichswehr und ihre Befehlshaber in dem Ausnahmezustand, der Zeit der Verhängung außergewöhnlicher Maßnahmen und der vorübergehenden Außerkraftsetzung der in der Reichsverfassung festgelegten Grundrechte der Deutschen, haben sollen. Und diese Stellung der Reichswehr bedarf einer Abgrenzung gegenüber den bürgerlichen Reichsbehörden und noch mehr den bürgerlichen Behörden der Einzelstaaten, insbesondere gegenüber ihren Verwaltungsbehörden und den Dienststellen der Polizei.
Poincaré siegt ohne Widerstand
Der Zwischenfall Louis Marin ist heute bei Kammerschluß von Poincaré in einigen Minuten erledigt worden. Poincaré bestieg, als die Kammer die Budgetberatung beendet hatte, die Tribüne und erklärte, daß er die Vertagung der Interpellation des Radikalen Hulin über die Rede des Pensionsministers Marin verlangen müsse.