The Montgomery Advertiser
- FIFTEEN PER CENT INCOME TAX CREDIT MELLON'S NEW ANTE
- LOVE LETTERS FROM CHOIR SINGER ADD INTEREST TO TRIAL
- PLANS WAR AGAINST LIQUOR SMUGGLING
The Montgomery Advertiser's front page of November 16, 1926, carried three Associated Press dispatches. From Washington, Secretary Mellon said taxpayers could safely be given at least a 15 per cent credit on next year's income taxes, basing the figure on an expected $300,000,000 surplus and going beyond President Coolidge's earlier 10 and 12½ per cent proposals. From Somerville, N.J., the Hall-Mills murder trial heard Mrs. Mills's sister testify about the choir singer's love for the Rev. Edward Hall, listened to her letters being read to the jury, and saw the state call a witness to counter one of its own. From Mobile, prohibition, coast guard and local officials adopted plans to suppress liquor smuggling on the Mississippi coast through closer cooperation.
Translation
FIFTEEN PER CENT INCOME TAX CREDIT MELLON'S NEW ANTE
WASHINGTON, Nov. 15. - (AP) - Secretary Mellon today again boosted the ante on the plan of President Coolidge for income tax credit, declaring it would be safe to permit taxpayers a saving of at least 15 per cent on their next year's income levies. The 15 per cent minimum credit was predicated, Mr. Mellon explained, on a prospective surplus of $300,000,000 for this fiscal year. First estimates made by the president indicated a surplus of $200,000,000 and on that ground he proposed a 10 per cent credit which later was boosted to 12½ per cent.
LOVE LETTERS FROM CHOIR SINGER ADD INTEREST TO TRIAL
SOMERVILLE, N. J., Nov. 15. - (AP) - An issue of veracity between two state witnesses, appearing out of a clear sky in the Hall-Mills case today, preempted for a time the place in the spotlight occupied by the love affair of the Rev. Edward W. Hall and Mrs. Eleanor R. Mills, slain with him four years ago. Between testimony of a sister of Mrs. Mills, that the slain choir singer was not ashamed of her love for the rector of the New Brunswick church, the reading to the jury of letters from Mrs. Mills to Mr. Hall, the state introduced a witness to neutralize the testimony of another state witness. The latter had testified that he could not identify Mrs. Hall and her two brothers, on trial for the murder of Mrs. Mills.
PLANS WAR AGAINST LIQUOR SMUGGLING
MOBILE, ALA., Nov. 15. - (AP) - At a conference of prohibition directors, coast guard officers, county and city officials here today, plans to bring about the suppression of liquor smuggling along the Mississippi coast were adopted. Closer cooperation between federal, state and city law enforcement activities was discussed and plans adopted for carrying out the state enforcement with harmonious action at all times.
Context
How Mellon's credit differed from Coolidge's refund
The Advertiser presented Mellon's 15 per cent figure as one more step up from the president's 10 and 12½ per cent, but the weekly TIME read the episode differently a week later. According to TIME, Coolidge had suggested refunding 10 or 12 per cent of income and corporation taxes payable in 1926, a scheme under which 90 per cent of income taxpayers would have received refunds of only 11 cents to $1.69. Mellon instead wanted the surplus credited to income taxes payable in 1927, arguing that there was no time to pass legislation covering the December 15, 1926, payment date. TIME judged the Treasury plan to be in reality a gentle repudiation of the Coolidge plan and a rebuke to Democratic zeal for a general tax cut, and it reported that the White House spokesman said the next day he was inclined to favor the Mellon plan. Read against TIME's account, the Advertiser's headline captures the larger percentage but not the shift to a different tax year.
What became of the surplus Mellon wanted to return
TIME expected Congress, either by action or inaction, to decide the question at its winter session. Coolidge's budget message of December 1927 gives the outcome for that fiscal year: the surplus at June 30, 1927, reached $635,809,000, more than double Mellon's $300,000,000 forecast, helped by $414,000,000 from non-recurring sources, and $612,000,000 of it was applied to the public debt. The same message lists the tax reductions since 1920 as the acts of 1921, 1924 and 1926, the last cutting $422,000,000, and names no 1927 credit. TIME had also described Mellon's general policy as using the surplus to help retire the national debt. Taken together, these figures indicate that the money Mellon proposed in November 1926 to leave in taxpayers' pockets went instead to debt retirement, the course the Treasury had long preferred.
Why a 1922 double murder was on trial in 1926
The Hall-Mills case involved the Rev. Edward Wheeler Hall, an Episcopal priest, and Eleanor Mills, a member of his choir with whom he was having an affair; both were murdered on September 14, 1922, in Franklin Township, New Jersey. Harold Schechter, writing in The Yale Review, notes that a batch of love letters was found scattered in the grass around the corpses, and that a grand jury failed to issue an indictment after five days of hearings. The case came back because of the New York Daily Mirror: Schechter writes that the tabloid's strident calls for action forced New Jersey's governor to reopen it, and Wikipedia records that Governor A. Harry Moore ordered a second investigation and a trial in 1926. The trial that the Advertiser followed through its letters and contested witnesses ended on December 3, 1926, when all three defendants were acquitted.
How the Somerville trial became a national press event
Wikipedia notes that in the history of journalism the case is largely remembered for the vast, nationwide newspaper coverage it received. Schechter writes that the Somerville courthouse was crammed with hundreds of reporters who would file more than twelve million words, and that the New York Times not only kept four full-time stenographers on the scene but covered the case more extensively than the tabloids. The Advertiser's front page shows the reach of that coverage: a Montgomery paper far from New Jersey ran the day's testimony, including the reading of Mrs. Mills's letters, through an Associated Press dispatch placed alongside national tax policy and local enforcement news.
Mobile's 1923 raid and the call for cooperation
According to Yellowhammer News, federal agents armed with search warrants swept across Mobile on November 13, 1923, and arrested 117 people, among them a bank president, a shipbuilding executive, the Mobile County sheriff and five deputy sheriffs. The same account says ships filled with liquor anchored just beyond the three-mile limit off Mobile's Gulf coast, and that protection bribes paid to local law enforcement officials ensured no one was arrested until federal agents acted. Local officials then retaliated by arresting U.S. Attorney Aubrey Boyles, who had directed the raid. Against that open conflict between federal and local authorities three years earlier, the 1926 Mobile conference's stress on closer federal, state and city cooperation and on harmonious action at all times reads as an attempt to repair a relationship that had failed publicly, with coast guard officers also taking part.
Original
FIFTEEN PER CENT INCOME TAX CREDIT MELLON'S NEW ANTE
WASHINGTON, Nov. 15. - (AP) - Secretary Mellon today again boosted the ante on the plan of President Coolidge for income tax credit, declaring it would be safe to permit taxpayers a saving of at least 15 per cent on their next year's income levies. The 15 per cent minimum credit was predicated, Mr. Mellon explained, on a prospective surplus of $ 300, 000, 000 for this fiscal year. First estimates made by the president indicated a surplus of $ 200, 000, 000 and on that ground he proposed a 10 per cent credit which later was boosted to 12 1-2 per cent.
LOVE LETTERS FROM CHOIR SINGER ADD INTEREST TO TRIAL
SOMERVILLE, N. J., Nov. 15. - (AP) - An issue of veracity between two state witnesses, appearing out of a clear sky in the Hall-Mills case today, preempted for a time the place in the spotlight occupied by the love affair of the Rev. Edward W. Hall and Mrs. Eleanor R. Mills, slain with him four years ago. Between testimony of a sister of Mrs. Mills, that the slain choir singer was not ashamed of her love for the rector of the New Brunswick church, the reading to the jury of letters from Mrs. Mills to Mr. Hall, the state introduced a witness to neutralize the testimony of another state witness. The latter had testified that he could not identify Mrs. Hall and her two brothers, on trial for the murder of Mrs. Mills.
PLANS WAR AGAINST LIQUOR SMUGGLING
MOBILE, ALA., Nov. 15. - (AP) - At a conference of prohibition directors, coast guard officers, county and city officials here today, plans to bring about the suppression of liquor smuggling along the Mississippi coast were adopted. Closer cooperation between federal, state and city law enforcement activities was discussed and plans adopted for carrying out the state enforcement with harmonious action at all times.
Source: Holding institution